Do I need an X-ray or MRI for back pain?

1. Do I need an X-ray or MRI for back pain?

Most people with back pain don't need a scan

When your back hurts, it's understandable to want to know exactly what's causing it. Patients sometimes arrive at the clinic expecting that an X-ray or MRI will provide the answer.

Sometimes imaging is extremely useful. But for most episodes of uncomplicated back pain, a scan isn't necessary — and it doesn't always tell us what's causing the pain.

What can we learn without a scan?

A detailed history and physical examination can tell us a great deal.

We'll ask about how your symptoms started, where you feel them, what makes them better or worse and whether you have symptoms such as pain, numbness or weakness in the legs.

The examination may then include assessment of your movement, joints, muscles and nervous system.

For many people, that's enough information to decide whether conservative treatment is appropriate without immediately arranging imaging.

Why doesn't everyone get an MRI?

One reason is that scans frequently show changes that aren't actually causing symptoms.

Disc bulges, disc degeneration, arthritic changes and other findings become increasingly common as we get older and can also be found in people who have no back pain at all.

In other words, an MRI can show us what your spine looks like, but that doesn't automatically tell us why it hurts.

This is why imaging findings always need to be considered alongside your symptoms and clinical examination.

When might imaging be appropriate?

There are circumstances where an X-ray, MRI or other investigation can provide important information.

We may consider imaging when the history or examination suggests that there could be an underlying problem requiring further investigation, when significant neurological symptoms are present, following certain injuries, or when symptoms aren't behaving as we'd normally expect.

The type of imaging matters too. X-rays and MRI scans answer different questions, so one isn't simply a “better” version of the other.

At College Chiropractic, if we believe imaging is clinically appropriate, we can arrange private X-rays, MRI or diagnostic ultrasound as appropriate.

Equally, if we don't think a scan is necessary, we'll explain why.

What about severe pain?

The severity of pain alone doesn't necessarily tell us how serious a problem is.

Musculoskeletal back pain can sometimes be extremely painful without being dangerous. Conversely, some conditions requiring further investigation don't necessarily produce dramatic pain.

That's why we consider the whole clinical picture, rather than making decisions based solely on a pain score.

The important thing is getting the right assessment

If you're experiencing back pain, you don't need to decide for yourself whether you need an X-ray or MRI before making an appointment.

Our job is to assess you, explain what we find and determine whether further investigation is likely to be useful.

Concerned about your back pain?

REQUEST AN APPOINTMENT →

This article provides general information and isn't a substitute for individual medical advice. New loss of bladder or bowel control, numbness around the saddle/genital area, rapidly progressing weakness or other severe or unusual symptoms require urgent medical assessment.

Previous
Previous

What exactly is Sciatica?